It's easy to get excited about a job offer and make a decision based on emotions, only to regret it later. This spreadsheet allows you to quantitatively compare up to 3 job offers relative to your current job on 38 different factors. The score is totaled out of 100 at the top.
The spreadsheet has placeholder information and data to show you how it works. Feel free to rename any of the factors that you want. Obviously, put the appropriate company names, job offer titles, compensation numbers, and ratings in for your situation.